Serious Comments/Critiques

[Nate Taylor]

Hey, everytone! If you're working on a project (animation or not, homework or not) and would like some serious constructive criticism and/or comments on your work, post it here!

Please remember to keep your comments polite... we don't want to just bash each other's projects. However, please post if you have helpful input on a project that gets put up here.


------------------------------------------------------


As long as I've started this thread, here's a WIP digital painting I'm doing based on This Sketch:

it's still largely unfinished and unrefined, as you may note... I have much tweaking and color fixing and painting to do, but I have to finish painting it first.
Anyway, here's links to the images in order of progress:
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3

and the most completed version thus far: Phase 4

------------------------------------------------------

So if you have thoughts and/or input, please feel free to (politely) state them!

Cheers
-Nate Taylor

PS. If this thread gets cluttered, we'll start different threads to keep the C&C organized.

[Nate Taylor]

OK, everyone. I've finished (for now) the painting to my liking: Click Here to See

I'll probably realize that I want to change something later, but for now I'm pretty happy with it.

Follow that link to see what you all think!
-Nate

[Tracey Tucker]

Dude, I'm sorry I didn't respond to this sooner. It looks awesome! At first glance I thought it was done on Maya!!

[Nate Taylor]

Thanks! Hahah, it has been a while since I posted that-

I am a 3D artist mostly, so it makes some sense that it would look Maya'd, I suppose. I think much better in 3D than in 2D.